LLMs and the Reflexivity of Orthodoxy
Published:
Hegel is commonly known as the thesis-antithesis-synthesis guy. If you type into Google "explain hegel"1, the AI Overview will helpfully explain the "Hegelian Dialectic (Thesis, Antithesis, Synthesis)" where "an initial idea (thesis) generates its opposite (antithesis), and the tension between them resolves into a higher truth or state (synthesis)". Yet type into the same search box "is hegel the thesis-antithesis-synthesis guy", and the AI Overview will also helpfully, but this time correctly, tell you "no, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel never used the terms 'thesis, antithesis, and synthesis' to describe his philosophy" and then explain "where the myth came from".2
Where Myths Come From
Gustav Mueller tells the tale of how Hegel's life as the thesis-antithesis-synthesis (t-a-s) guy began. It all starts with Johann Gottlieb Fichte, the true inventor of the t-a-s triad. Commenting on Fichte, Hegel explained how Fichte derived t-a-s from Immanuel Kant, but called it a "lifeless schema" whose "repetition, when once it is familiar, becomes as boring as the repetition of any bit of sleight-of-hand once we see through it." Given these views, Hegel predictably did not use t-a-s in his work, and early students and commentators didn't explain Hegel through t-a-s either. The first sparks of Hegel's life as the t-a-s guy began with Heinrich Moritz Chalybäus, whose "brilliant hunch" in his popular lecture notes that a "methodological thesis, antithesis, and synthesis" was "an example or schema for all that follows" was read by Karl Marx. Marx "took the hunch and spread it into a deadly, abstract machinery". Once Marx had provided the initial caricature, "writers of textbooks in the history of philosophy copied it from their predecessors", happy to not need to do their own interpretation.
It would be easy to portray this as a one-off: an impossibly incomprehensible3 German philosopher got misinterpreted by a theorist who'd go on to influence just about everything. Yet simply passing along received "knowledge", like philosophy textbook authors did, is far more common than we'd like to think. A clever study based on citation misprints estimates 70-90% of citations are copied out of other papers. There even exist "a number of important economics citations" where "people cite them, it is standard to cite them, referees may ask you to cite them, and the underlying paper does not exist anywhere and never has".
Claude's Library
Google's AI Overviews, while popular, do not represent anything close to the capabilities of modern LLMs. When the small search model is fed a bunch of low-quality YouTube videos by the "explain hegel" results, it reproduces their claim Hegel is t-a-s. When the same model gets the results for "is hegel the thesis-antithesis-synthesis guy" containing posts from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy and r/Hegel explicitly claiming no, it also reproduces those claims. If you were to instead ask Claude Fable 5.2 to "explain hegel" without any web search tools, it would tell you "the famous 'thesis–antithesis–synthesis' formula is not Hegel's own".4 LLMs have a built-in account of what is true, but where does this come from?
LLM training pipelines tend to have three key stages5: pre-training, a mid-training phase everyone'd like to forget about, and post-training. In the pre-training phase, LLMs are trained to predict the probability that any given token of text will come next given the previous text. These probabilities are given a loss according to KL-divergence with the true answer, which the model learns to minimize over time. This pre-training phase imparts the model with some information derived from the text.6 The more, and higher "quality", the text models are trained on, the better the model tends to be at downstream use-cases. (Hence LLM companies aggressively scraping the web, obtaining books, etc.)
With pre-training the model knows Hegel the t-a-s guy, Hegel the not t-a-s guy, and Hegel the esotericist as all possible completions. The reason Fable consistently says t-a-s was not Hegel when asked to explain Hegel is because of post-training. In modern post-training setups, the LLMs are asked to complete tasks given a certain prompt. The LLMs are randomly sampled many times, often given the ability to use tools (like web search, the ability to run commands, etc.), and attempts are given a reward based on a grader. The weights are updated in the direction of high-reward samples and away from low-reward samples. The graders themselves can be combinations of LLM-as-judge (possibly using rubrics), verifiable rewards (like getting the correct answer to a math problem, having its program compile successfully, etc.), or other heuristics. Over time this pushes the model towards producing answers the LLM creators want. (Although production use of LLMs can be a bit "off-label" since the models may be aware there isn't a grader due to the nature of the prompts and their environment.)
I conjecture this process causes models to roughly converge towards what could be called "expert orthodoxy". Absent any real ground truth for what was in Hegel's head, graders instead can check against what Hegel experts say. Reproducing expert answers is a reasonable thing for LLMs to do, because experts tend to be right more than non-experts.
Infinite Expert Orthodoxy
How does the process of knowledge acquisition change once everyone has instant free expert answers? One potential effect is it causes people's writing and opinions to reflect expert orthodoxy much more than they do now. The Financial Times found that in simulated conversations "different AI platforms behave in subtly different ways", but "all of them nudge people away from the most extreme positions and towards more moderate and expert-aligned stances". If a writer asks for comments on their writing from an LLM, it's more likely to push them towards what it regards as true.
This could potentially result in orthodoxy becoming much more sticky. A key point of They Say / I Say is that writing should be controversial. If everyone already agrees with something, there's not much point in saying it. What is now orthodoxy was once controversial. LLMs could have the potential to undermine this cycle. When LLMs write all the papers, and LLMs peer-review all the papers, will new ideas be able to take hold?
On the Revolt of the Reader
One proposed solution is to ensure LLMs only play a secondary role in knowledge production. Pangram currently does a good job of identifying AI writing, and Bryan Cantrill's The revolt of the reader proposes readers will be taking advantage of this. Yet many readers seem to not care: Hacker News is now filled with AI writing and LLM-generated posts regularly go viral on the site formerly known as Twitter (although the account-driven nature lets you actively avoid it over time). It seems many readers have little desire to revolt, and there's a good chance more will give up the revolt once LLM writing becomes less noticeable. For domains like programming, where many aspects are easily measurable, LLMs can probably make their own progress, but for domains like philosophy or politics without targets other than expert opinion, I am worried.
- ^ Searched on 2026/11/11.
Google's AI Overview
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770–1831) was a German idealist philosopher who viewed reality not as a collection of static objects, but as a single, dynamic, and evolving process. He believed that history, nature, and human thought are all moving forward through a rational process toward total self-awareness and freedom. Core Concepts • Geist (Spirit or Mind): Hegel used Geist to describe the underlying universal mind or reason that drives reality. He saw the universe not as dead matter, but as Spirit slowly waking up and understanding itself through human history and consciousness. • The Hegelian Dialectic (Thesis, Antithesis, Synthesis): Hegel explained that change happens through a conflict of ideas. An initial idea (thesis) generates its opposite (antithesis), and the tension between them resolves into a higher truth or state (synthesis). • Sublation (Aufheben): This is Hegel's term for the process where a contradiction is simultaneously canceled, preserved, and lifted to a higher level—keeping the valuable parts of an old idea while moving past its flaws. • The Master–Slave Dialectic (Lordship and Bondage): A famous story in Hegel's work where two self-conscious beings meet. To truly know who you are, you need recognition from someone else. This power struggle shows that true freedom comes through mutual recognition and interdependence rather than domination. • History as the Progress of Freedom: Hegel viewed history as a meaningful, non-random story where humanity gradually expands its understanding of freedom through laws, ethics, and the state. Major Works • Phenomenology of Spirit (1807): Traces how individual human consciousness climbs the ladder from basic sensory perception up to absolute knowing. • Science of Logic (1812–1816): Explores pure logical categories and how concepts build upon one another internally. • Elements of the Philosophy of Right (1821): Examines how abstract rights and personal morality grow into real-world ethical life (Sittlichkeit), family, civil society, and the state. You can explore primary texts and introductory notes via the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy or read simplified breakdowns on the Marxists Internet Archive Hegel Help Pages. To see a quick visual breakdown of how Hegel's ideas and dialectical method work in practice, watch this overview: 1m Hegel's Philosophy in 10 Minutes 82K views · 5 years ago YouTube · ARTFORINTROVERT Would you like to dive deeper into a specific part of Hegel, such as: • The Hegelian dialectic and how it influenced Karl Marx? • The Master–Slave dialectic? • A beginner-friendly reading order for his books? - ^ Also searched on 2026/11/11:
Google's AI Overview
No, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel never used the terms "thesis, antithesis, and synthesis" to describe his philosophy. Where the Myth Came From • Johann Gottlieb Fichte: The philosopher Fichte first used a triadic language of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis in his work, which influenced later thinkers. • Heinrich Moritz Chalybäus: The popularization of the rigid "thesis-antithesis-synthesis" formula is widely credited to the philosopher Chalybäus, who used it as a pedagogical tool to explain post-Kantian German idealism. • Hegel's Actual Method: Hegel rejected rigid external formulas. According to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Hegel never adopted Fichte's triadic scheme. Instead, his dialectic moves through determinate negation and Aufhebung (sublation)—a process where a concept reveals its own internal contradictions, breaks down, and is preserved and elevated into a more comprehensive truth, rather than mechanically gluing a thesis and antithesis together into a middle-ground synthesis. Would you like to explore how determinate negation actually works in Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit? - ^ Or so I'm told...
- ^ Asked 2026/11/12:
Claude Fable 5.2's Answer
# Hegel in a nutshell Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770–1831) was a German philosopher whose central claim is that **reality is not a fixed set of things but a rational process that develops over time, and human thought and history are how that process comes to understand itself.** ## The core ideas **1. Dialectic: development through contradiction.** Hegel thinks ideas, societies, and forms of consciousness contain internal tensions. When a position is pushed to its limits, it reveals its own inadequacy and gives rise to a richer one. The key term is *Aufhebung* (often translated "sublation"): the old position is at once cancelled, preserved, and raised to a higher level. Nothing is simply thrown away, and earlier stages survive as parts of later ones. The famous "thesis–antithesis–synthesis" formula is not Hegel's own. It's a later simplification, and he rarely spoke that way. **2. Geist (Spirit or Mind).** *Geist* is the collective mind of humanity: our shared culture, institutions, language, and ways of understanding. Hegel treats it as something that develops historically. Individuals think within the frameworks their era provides. **3. History has a direction.** For Hegel, history is "the progress of the consciousness of freedom." In the ancient despotisms, one person was free (the ruler). In Greece and Rome, some were free. In the modern world, the principle emerges that all are free. History is messy and violent, but he thinks it has an underlying logic. **4. The Absolute.** The endpoint of the process is "absolute knowing": the point where mind recognizes that the world it has been trying to understand is not alien to it, and that the structures of thought and the structures of reality are ultimately the same. This is why Hegel is called an *absolute idealist*. **5. Selfhood requires recognition.** In the famous master–slave dialectic, Hegel argues that you can't be a full self-conscious person in isolation. You need to be recognized by another self you in turn recognize as free. Domination fails even for the dominator, because recognition from someone you've reduced to a thing is worthless. ## Why he matters Hegel made philosophy historical. After him, it became hard to treat ideas, moral values, or human nature as timeless, since they have histories and make sense only within them. Marx, existentialism, pragmatism, critical theory, and much of modern social thought are either extensions of Hegel or rebellions against him.Major works
- ***Phenomenology of Spirit* (1807):** Traces the journey of consciousness from naive sense-experience up to absolute knowing. It contains the master–slave dialectic and is his most famous and most difficult book. - ***Science of Logic* (1812–16):** Not formal logic but an account of the basic categories of thought (being, nothing, becoming, essence, concept) and how each generates the next. - ***Encyclopedia of the Philosophical Sciences* (1817):** His full system in outline: logic, nature, spirit. - ***Elements of the Philosophy of Right* (1820):** His political philosophy. Freedom is realized not in isolation but through institutions: family, civil society, and the state. - **Lectures** on history, art, religion, and the history of philosophy, published posthumously and often more readable.Common misunderstandings
- **"The real is rational" means whatever exists is good.** Hegel meant that what is truly *actual*, in the sense of realizing its essential nature, is rational. He did not mean every existing institution is justified. - **He worshipped the Prussian state.** This is disputed. His ideal state includes constitutional government, rule of law, and civil liberties that Prussia lacked. - **He declared the "end of history."** He thought the *principle* of universal freedom had been achieved in the modern era, not that events would stop. - **Geist is a supernatural being.** Interpretations vary. Some read Hegel metaphysically (a cosmic mind), while many contemporary scholars read Geist as human social and rational life with no supernatural element.## Where to start Hegel's own prose is notoriously hard. A good path is Peter Singer's *Hegel: A Very Short Introduction*, then Hegel's Introduction to the *Lectures on the Philosophy of History*, his most accessible text. I can go deeper on any piece. The dialectic, the master–slave section, and his relationship to Kant or Marx are the usual next steps.Influence and critics
- **Marx** kept the dialectic but "turned Hegel on his head": material and economic conditions, not ideas, drive history. - **Kierkegaard** attacked the system for swallowing the individual, and existentialism grew from that protest. - **Schopenhauer** called him a charlatan, and **Russell** and early analytic philosophy rejected him as obscure. - **Twentieth-century revivals** include Kojève, whose lectures shaped Sartre, Lacan, and Fukuyama, as well as the Frankfurt School and contemporary philosophers like Robert Brandom, Robert Pippin, and Charles Taylor. - ^ As an example, see Microsoft's MAI-Thinking-1: Building a Hill-Climbing Machine
- ^ Gwern provides some intuition on why this works. The compression approach is motivated by Solomonoff Induction and Marcus Hutter's work on AIXI, specifically the observation that "being able to compress well is closely related to acting intelligently". For a perspective on this view beyond text, see Jürgen Schmidhuber's Driven by Compression Progress